Skip the wait and book online! New patients can self-schedule directly online in minutes – no phone call needed. Schedule Today!

Total Shoulder Replacement: Anatomic & Reverse Options

Living With Shoulder Arthritis Pain

If your shoulder aches when you reach for a high shelf, wakes you up at night or no longer lets you lift your arm the way it used to, you know how much shoulder arthritis can affect your daily life. Getting dressed, carrying groceries, sleeping on your side and playing a round of golf can all become harder than they should be.

When physical therapy, medication and injections no longer control the pain, total shoulder replacement may be the next step toward getting back to the activities you enjoy. At Panorama Orthopedics & Spine Center, our shoulder replacement surgeons perform both anatomic and reverse total shoulder replacement for patients across Denver and Colorado.

Anatomic & Reverse Options | Conservative Care First 
Istock 1847472397

Schedule Your Appointment

Schedule Online
Call (303) 233-1223

Article Written by
Dr. Daniel Haber, MD
Board-Certified Orthopedic Surgeon, Shoulder & Knee

What Is Total Shoulder Replacement?

Total shoulder replacement, also called total shoulder arthroplasty, is a surgery that removes the damaged surfaces of the shoulder joint and replaces them with smooth artificial parts. Your shoulder is a ball-and-socket joint. The ball at the top of your upper arm bone (the humerus) rests in a shallow socket on your shoulder blade (the glenoid). When the cartilage that cushions those surfaces wears away, bone grinds on bone. The result is pain, stiffness and lost motion.

During a total shoulder replacement, the worn ball is replaced with a polished metal ball and the socket is resurfaced with a durable plastic component. The goal is straightforward: relieve pain and restore the motion you need for everyday life.

Shoulder replacement surgery is a well-established procedure and one of the fastest-growing joint replacements in the United States. Hear what recovery looked like for one of Dr. Haber’s patients in Mark’s shoulder story.

Anatomic vs. Reverse Total Shoulder Replacement

There are two main types of total shoulder replacement. The right one for you depends largely on the health of your rotator cuff, the group of muscles and tendons that keeps the ball centered in the socket and helps lift your arm.

Anatomic Total Shoulder Replacement

An anatomic total shoulder replacement recreates the shoulder’s natural design, with a new ball on the upper arm and a new socket on the shoulder blade. It is typically recommended for patients with osteoarthritis whose rotator cuff tendons are intact and working well.

Best for: osteoarthritis with an intact, working rotator cuff.

Reverse Total Shoulder Replacement

A reverse total shoulder replacement switches those positions. The ball is attached to the shoulder blade and the socket is attached to the upper arm. This changes the mechanics of the joint so the large deltoid muscle can lift the arm in place of a damaged rotator cuff. Reverse shoulder replacement is often the preferred option for patients with a large rotator cuff tear that cannot be repaired, arthritis combined with rotator cuff failure, certain complex fractures in older adults or a previous shoulder replacement that needs revision.

Best for: shoulder arthritis with a torn rotator cuff, large rotator cuff tears that cannot be repaired, rotator cuff tear arthropathy, complex fractures and revision surgery.

Partial Shoulder Replacement

In select cases, only the ball is replaced. This procedure, called hemiarthroplasty, is usually reserved for specific fracture patterns or shoulders with a healthy socket.

This may be recommended in young patients with arthritis and patients with isolated avascular necrosis of the humeral head (disruption of the blood supply to the ball). The materials used in partial shoulder replacement have improved significantly in the last few years, making this an appealing option for more people than previously thought.

Your surgeon will recommend an approach based on your imaging, exam, age and activity goals.

Conditions Treated With Shoulder Replacement

Shoulder replacement may be recommended for:

  • Osteoarthritis, the wear-and-tear arthritis that is the most common reason for shoulder replacement
  • Rheumatoid arthritis and other inflammatory arthritis
  • Rotator cuff tear arthropathy, shoulder joint dysfunction, which may include arthritis, due to a long-standing rotator cuff tear
  • Post-traumatic arthritis following a fracture or dislocation
  • Avascular necrosis, a loss of blood supply that causes the bone of the humeral head to collapse
  • Severe fractures of the upper arm bone
  • A failed prior shoulder surgery or replacement

Am I a Candidate for Total Shoulder Replacement?

At Panorama, surgery is never the first step. Most patients with shoulder arthritis start with conservative care, which may include:

  • Physical therapy to strengthen the muscles around the shoulder and preserve motion
  • Anti-inflammatory medication and activity changes
  • Corticosteroid injections, Platelet Rich Plasma (PRP) injections and other interventional pain solutions

You may be a candidate for total shoulder replacement if:

  • Shoulder pain interferes with daily activities like dressing, bathing or reaching overhead
  • You have moderate to severe pain at rest or pain that wakes you at night
  • You have lost significant motion or strength in the shoulder
  • Conservative treatments have not provided lasting relief
  • X-rays or other imaging show advanced joint damage

An evaluation with a shoulder specialist, including X-rays and sometimes a CT scan or MRI, is the best way to know whether replacement makes sense for you and which type fits your shoulder.

What to Expect: Before, During and After Surgery

Before Surgery

Preparation starts several weeks ahead. You may have a preoperative medical evaluation, imaging to plan the size and position of your implant and a review of your medications. It also helps to prepare your home: move everyday items to waist height and arrange help with meals and driving for the first few weeks. Our Shoulder Replacement Guidebook and pre-op shoulder exercises walk you through each step.

During Surgery

Total shoulder replacement usually takes 1 to 2 hours. It is performed under anesthesia, and a nerve block is commonly used to keep the shoulder numb for 1-3 days afterwards. This minimizes the amount of pain medication needed after surgery. Your surgeon makes an incision at the front of the shoulder, removes the damaged bone and cartilage and positions the new components.

After Surgery

Many patients go home the same day or the day after surgery, depending on their health and needs. You will wear a sling for roughly four weeks to protect the healing shoulder. In most instances your surgeon will have you start physical therapy within 1-2 weeks of surgery. Learn how to adjust and wear your sling before your procedure so you feel confident at home.

Shoulder Replacement Recovery Timeline

Every recovery is different, but most patients follow a similar path:

  • 1-4 weeks: Sling use, pain control and passive range of motion only (the shoulder may move when someone else moves it for you). Physical therapy begins in the first 1-2 weeks.
  • 4-6 weeks: The sling is no longer worn, and the shoulder may be used for simple activities of daily living such as washing hair in the shower, reaching overhead to open a cupboard or lifting up a water bottle. Physical therapy continues.
  • 8-12 weeks: Physical therapy and home exercises focus on regaining maximum range of motion and building muscular endurance of the shoulder.
  • 3-6 months and beyond: Physical therapy focuses on strengthening the shoulder and gradual return to full activity. Most patients return to golf, swimming, skiing, pickleball and other activities, with surgeon approval, around 4-5 months after surgery.

Your surgeon and physical therapist will adjust this timeline to your progress and the type of replacement you had. Keeping up with your home exercise program is one of the most important things you can do for an excellent result.

Risks and Results

Total shoulder replacement has a strong track record. Most patients experience significant pain relief and better function, and many shoulder replacements last 15 years or longer.

As with any surgery, there are risks. They include infection, blood clots, nerve injury, fracture around the implant, dislocation and loosening or wear of the components over time. Some patients also have lasting limits on heavy lifting. Your surgeon will review your personal risk factors and the steps our team takes to reduce them.

Why Choose Panorama for Shoulder Replacement

  • A dedicated shoulder care team offering everything from physical therapy to anatomic and reverse shoulder replacement
  • Castle Connolly Recognized Top Doctors who perform more than 150 total shoulder replacements per year
  • Part of our joint replacement program and more than 60 years of orthopedic care in Denver
  • Same-day and next-day appointments at convenient Denver metro locations

If shoulder pain is limiting your life, schedule an appointment to find out whether total shoulder replacement is right for you.

Panorama Orthopedics & Spine Center. Serving Denver, the Front Range and communities across Colorado.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Long Does a Shoulder Replacement Last?

Many shoulder replacements last 15 years or longer, and many patients keep theirs for life. Your activity level, bone quality and the type of implant all play a role.

What Is the Difference Between a Total and a Reverse Shoulder Replacement?

An anatomic total shoulder replacement keeps the ball and socket in their natural positions and relies on a healthy rotator cuff. A reverse shoulder replacement swaps them so the deltoid muscle can power the arm when the rotator cuff is badly damaged. See the full comparison above.

How Painful Is Shoulder Replacement Surgery?

A nerve block and a combination of pain medications help keep you comfortable in the first days after surgery. Most patients find that post-surgical discomfort eases steadily over the first few weeks, and many say it is more manageable than the arthritis pain they lived with before.

How Long Will I Stay in the Hospital?

Many patients go home the same day or after one night. Your surgeon will recommend the right plan based on your overall health and support at home.

When Can I Drive After Shoulder Replacement?

Most patients can drive once out of their sling (generally after 4 weeks), are off prescription pain medication and are cleared by their surgeon.

What Activities Can I Do After a Shoulder Replacement?

Many patients return to activities like walking, swimming, golf, gardening, strength training, skiing or snowboarding and jogging. Your surgeon may recommend avoiding heavy lifting and contact sports to protect the implant.

Is There an Age Limit for Shoulder Replacement?

There is no strict age limit. Candidacy depends on your pain, joint damage, overall health and goals. A consultation with a shoulder specialist is the best way to find out whether shoulder replacement is right for you.